How can you tell if watercolor is good quality?

You can identify good-quality watercolor by vibrant pigments, lasting color, and smooth application.

Understanding Watercolor Composition

Watercolor paint primarily consists of pigments suspended in a water-soluble binder, usually gum arabic. The composition of these elements significantly impacts the quality of the watercolor. High-quality watercolors contain more pigment and fewer fillers, resulting in better color vibrancy and longevity.

How can you tell if watercolor is good quality

Pigment Purity and Vibrancy

Pigments are the core of watercolor paints, providing color. High-quality watercolors use pure, finely ground pigments, offering enhanced vibrancy and a broader color spectrum. For instance, Cadmium Red offers a rich, deep hue, highly sought after in professional-grade paints. The purity of these pigments ensures that the colors do not muddy when mixed and retain their brilliance even when diluted.

Binder Quality and Consistency

The binder, typically gum arabic, affects the application and drying of the paint. A superior quality binder ensures even distribution of pigment, smooth application, and consistent texture. The consistency of the binder can also impact the paint’s transparency and affects how it adheres to the watercolor paper. A well-balanced binder contributes to the paint’s overall durability and resistance to fading over time.

Additives and Impurities

Additives in watercolor can include extenders and humectants to alter the paint’s properties, like drying time and flow. High-quality watercolors minimize unnecessary additives, which can dilute the pigment’s strength and impact the paint’s overall performance. Impurities in cheaper paints often result in a chalky texture and reduced color clarity. Premium brands invest in refining processes to ensure their watercolors are free from such detrimental impurities.

Assessing Watercolor Longevity and Permanence

The longevity and permanence of watercolors are critical factors that contribute to the enduring quality of watercolor artworks. These aspects depend on the lightfastness of the pigments, the chemical stability of the paint, and its resistance to moisture and other environmental factors.

Lightfastness Ratings

Lightfastness refers to the resistance of a pigment to fading when exposed to light. This property is essential for the longevity of watercolor paintings, especially those displayed in well-lit conditions. Pigments with high lightfastness ratings, such as ASTM I or II, can maintain their color for 100 years or more under typical museum conditions. The American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) provides these ratings, offering a reliable guide for artists to select long-lasting pigments.


Chemical Stability and Fading

The chemical stability of watercolor paints determines their resistance to fading, discoloration, or degradation over time. Paints formulated with chemically stable pigments and high-quality binders are less prone to these issues. For example, synthetic organic pigments often offer greater stability compared to some natural organic pigments, which might be more susceptible to environmental factors. Regular exposure to pollutants and varying pH levels can accelerate the degradation process, making chemical stability a vital consideration for artists.

Moisture Resistance and Durability

Moisture resistance is crucial for watercolor paints, as water is both a medium for application and a potential source of damage. High-quality watercolors resist reactivation and bleeding when exposed to humidity or subsequent layers of paint. This characteristic ensures the durability of the artwork and allows for techniques like layering and glazing without compromising earlier work. The interaction of the paint with the paper also plays a role; watercolor papers with good sizing and appropriate texture can enhance the paint’s moisture resistance and overall durability.

Evaluating Watercolor Brands and Price Points

When choosing watercolor paints, artists must navigate a variety of brands and price points, balancing cost with quality to find the best value for their needs. Understanding the differences between high-end and budget brands, considering the relationship between cost and quality, and assessing brand reputation and reviews are crucial steps in this process.

High-End vs. Budget Brands

High-end watercolor brands, like Winsor & Newton or Daniel Smith, are known for their superior pigment quality, greater permanence, and consistent performance. These brands often use purer pigments and higher pigment loads, resulting in vibrant, long-lasting colors. For instance, a tube of high-end watercolor paint can cost anywhere from $10 to $25 or more, but the investment often pays off in the quality of the final artwork. On the other hand, budget brands, such as Cotman or Sakura, provide more affordable options, with prices ranging from $3 to $10 per tube. While they are suitable for beginners or practice work, budget brands may have more fillers and lower pigment concentration, leading to less vibrancy and reduced longevity.

Cost vs. Quality Considerations

The cost of watercolor paints can significantly vary, and while higher prices often correlate with better quality, this is not always a hard rule. Mid-range brands like M. Graham or Sennelier offer a balance, providing professional-grade quality at somewhat lower prices than top-tier brands. Artists need to consider their specific needs, such as the type of work they are doing (professional work vs. practice), the importance of lightfastness and pigment quality, and their budget constraints. For example, an artist focusing on archival-quality commissions might prioritize high-end paints, while a hobbyist or student may find mid-range or budget brands adequate for their needs.

A Guide For Buying Watercolour Paints

Brand Reputation and Reviews

Brand reputation plays a significant role in evaluating watercolors. Established brands with a long history in the art supplies industry often have a proven track record of quality and reliability. For instance, Schmincke and Holbein are renowned for their exceptional quality, as evidenced by their widespread use among professional artists. Reading reviews and seeking recommendations from fellow artists can provide valuable insights into the performance and quality of different brands. Online platforms and forums offer a wealth of user experiences and feedback, helping artists make informed decisions based on their specific needs and preferences.

Watercolor Application and Performance

The application and performance of watercolors play a crucial role in the creative process and the final outcome of a painting. Key aspects like ease of mixing and blending, granulation and texture effects, as well as color lifting and layering capabilities, determine the versatility and expressiveness of watercolor paints.

Ease of Mixing and Blending

The ability to mix and blend colors seamlessly is essential for creating a wide range of hues and soft transitions in watercolor painting. High-quality watercolors offer smooth, easy mixing without losing their vibrancy. This quality allows artists to create an infinite palette of shades from a limited set of basic colors. For example, a good quality Ultramarine Blue should blend effortlessly with a Burnt Sienna to produce a range of natural browns and grays, offering both subtlety and depth. The ease of blending also depends on the paper’s quality; 100% cotton watercolor paper typically provides the best results.

Granulation and Texture Effects

Granulation refers to the property of some pigments to settle into the paper’s texture, creating a granular, mottled effect. This characteristic is particularly valued for its ability to add depth and dimension to a painting. Certain pigments, like Ultramarine Blue or Raw Sienna, are known for their granulating properties. Artists often use these effects to enhance landscapes, skies, and other natural elements. The degree of granulation varies between brands and is a critical consideration for artists looking to achieve specific textural effects.

Color Lifting and Layering Capabilities

Color lifting is the ability to remove or lighten a color from the paper, which is vital for corrections or creating highlights and textures. High-quality watercolors allow for easier lifting when damp, offering more control and flexibility. Layering, on the other hand, involves applying multiple layers of paint to build up color intensity and depth. Watercolors that maintain their transparency and vibrancy through multiple layers are highly prized. For instance, transparent watercolors like Quinacridone Gold or Phthalo Green are excellent for glazing techniques, allowing underlying colors to shine through, creating complex and luminous effects.

What are the key indicators of high-quality watercolors?

High-quality watercolors are characterized by vibrant pigments, excellent lightfastness (ASTM I or II), and a smooth, consistent binder.

Do more expensive watercolors always mean better quality?

Not necessarily. While premium brands can offer top-notch quality, mid-range brands like M. Graham provide professional-grade paints at a more affordable price point.

How can I assess the lightfastness of watercolors?

Check for ASTM ratings on the packaging. Ratings of I or II indicate excellent lightfastness, meaning colors won't fade for over 100 years.

Can watercolor paper affect the quality of the artwork?

Absolutely. 100% cotton watercolor paper with proper sizing enhances color vibrancy and allows for better blending and layering.

Are there any pigments known for granulation and texture effects?

Yes, pigments like Ultramarine Blue or Raw Sienna are known for their granulating properties, adding depth to paintings.

What is color lifting, and why is it important?

Color lifting is the ability to remove or lighten colors. High-quality watercolors offer easy lifting for corrections and highlights.

How can I evaluate watercolors for layering capabilities?

Transparent watercolors like Quinacridone Gold or Phthalo Green are excellent for layering, maintaining transparency and vibrancy through multiple layers.

Does the brand reputation matter when choosing watercolors?

Yes, established brands with a history of quality, like Winsor & Newton or Schmincke, often offer reliable performance and a wide range of colors. Reading reviews and artist recommendations can also help in decision-making.
Share the Post:

Our product